Does resistance training for
pitchers improve velocity and stamina? If there is improvement,
at what cost does it come? Does it cause accelerated wear and
tear to the pitchers muscular-skeletal system? Are mechanics
irreversibly altered in a negative way by using anything other
than a regulation size and weight baseball to train with? These
are questions that need to be answered by anyone contemplating
a resistance based training program.
Searching the Internet I was able to find quite
a number of research papers that address the issues posed
above. One research paper in particular was very convincing.
The authors review twenty-six separate studies on velocity
resistance training methods consisting of isotonic, ballistic,
medicine ball, isokinetic, overload baseballs, wall pulley,
weighted baseballs, Exer-genie and surgical tubing. Twenty-two
of the studies show an increase in velocity from resistance
training; three show no change and one showed a decrease.
See: Effects of General, Special, and Specific Resistance
Training on Throwing Velocity in Baseball: A Brief Review; J.
Strength Cond. Res. 15 (1): 148-156. 2001 by DeRenne, et
al.
Based on the above cited paper and numerous others,
the evidence appears to be overwhelming that resistance training
works to improve throwing velocity. With anything in life though
nothing is that simple, otherwise there would be near total
agreement across the baseball world on this issue and there
isn’t. There are still some unanswered questions.
I personally don't believe any training aid
or pitching technique will allow you to throw faster than you
were designed by nature to throw. When it comes to throwing
velocity everyone has a natural speed limit imposed on them
largely by genetics: height, limb length, fast-twitch muscle,
tendon and ligiment elasticity to name a few. There will always
be some who can throw faster than others even if everyone trained
identically and had the identical pitching technique. What
I think a good pitching training aid should do is to first and
foremost, help you to attain your top speed and attain it significantly
faster than without using a training aid. Once achieved, the
training aid should allow you to maintain your top speed with
less wear and tear or injury.
Some years back I became aware of weighted baseballs
as a pitching training aid. I considered having my sons use
them, but I had doubt at the time they might cause more harm
than good. My sons never used them for this reason. That was
before the Internet and the easy access to the information
it can provide. Over the last two years while developing the
Aerothrow I have done extensive reading of the available publications
on the subject. The vast majority of the research I have read,
including baseball authorities who have written about the subject
on their websites, strongly suggest weighted baseballs work
to increase velocity. I list some of the available publications
below for reference.
Granted that using weighted
baseballs as a pitching training aid will increase throwing
velocity, there is still the issue of wear and tear and injury.
It seems common sense that if ones mechanics are flawed, adding
weight to the ball one is training with will simply hasten
the occurrence of injury. Although some researchers and coaches
state that they have not witnessed any increase in injury from
using weighted baseballs, they admit that follow-up studies
are needed before stating that as fact. Also keep in mind that
a lot of the studies were done with high school and college
athletes. I would be very cautious about allowing anyone below
that age group to train with weighted baseballs.
to top |
Although the Aerothrow
is not a weighted baseball, it does use resistance to strengthen,
condition and coordinate. However, it does so by a means much
more benign in its impact to the pitcher than throwing a weighted
baseball. So if the available research shows that resistance
training in general and weighted baseballs specifically work
to increase the velocity and stamina of a pitcher, then using
the Aerothrow will obviously do the same but at much reduced
risk of wear and tear or injury.
One major opponent of using weighted baseballs
is Dick Mills, an ex Major Leaguer who once played a season
for the Boston Red Sox and who has in my opinion the best
website on the Internet www.pitching.com dedicated
to teaching proper pitching mechanics. He has come out very
strongly against using weighted balls. See
this article .
I respect his opinion greatly because of the wisdom I have
seen him display over the years in his understanding of pitching,
pitchers and the quality of coaching available, but I think
he may have this one detail wrong. There is just too much
overwhelming research against suggesting there is no benefit
to weighted balls. Dick’s main contention is that training
with the added weight will adversely affect ones pitching
mechanics. I believe that is true, but I also believe that
a pitcher can quickly readjust when returning to throwing
a regulation ball all the while retaining the increased throwing
strength gained from training with a weighted ball. By throwing
strength I don’t mean arm strength, I mean the total
body strength needed to throw a baseball.
I think another major factor that makes training
with weighted balls effective is the increased resistance created
by the added ball weight. Over time the increased resistance
causes the rotator cuff muscles to flex more while throwing
and that allows greater shoulder rotation (i.e. arm cocking).
See picture immediately below. In the studies I have read,
the amount of arm cocking achieved is one of the significant
differences between high velocity and low velocity pitchers.
See “Kinematic Differences Between Highly-Skilled and
Less-Skilled Baseball Pitchers” by Glenn S. Fleisig1,
et al., Presented at the 23rd Annual Meeting of the American
Society of Biomechanics, University of Pittsburgh October 21-23,
1999.

|